This was originally posted here on January 19, 2007.
Someone threw holy water on me once.
She
didn’t know me. She knew not my favorite color or novel or whether I
had gone to my high school prom. She hadn’t met my parents or my
children or my great-grandmother who, at 98, still smoked a pack of
Camels a day. She had no idea that I learned to read when I was just
four years
old or that geometric theorems gave me migraines. She never heard that
love song a pretty boy with a guitar had written for me or the story of
how I’d secretly longed to be a member of the Brat Pack since the
totally bitchin’ eighties and the arrival of Molly Ringwald. She’d
never seen that old home video of me breakdancing when I was nine or
that picture of my childhood pet, the great Gatsby.
She didn’t even know my name.
I
looked down at the drops of oily water freckling my arms and then back
at the stranger before me. The brochures and paperwork set out
methodically on the table just moments before were, no doubt, wet as
well. I stared at the smirk on her face and the blatant hatred in her
eyes for but a moment before returning to the task at hand.
Just as she didn’t need to know my name, I needed not her reasons.
As
I dabbed here and there with the paper towel, I wondered at my lack of
anger. The voice that had always been first with the quick retort and
witty debate was strangely silent. I looked around the room at all of
her supporters and their stern faces and then at those that I stood by…
She walked over to a group thick by the door and grinned in triumph at
her three children just as the beginning of the program was announced.
The woman in nun’s robes next to me laid a hand on my shoulder and
squeezed gently in encouragement before taking her place at the podium.
The button on my shirt said, “My Body. My Choice.”
The brochure in my hand said, “Keep It Safe. Keep It Legal .”
And the banner across the entranceway said, “This IS What Catholic Looks Like.”
Although
I’ll always harbor a little regret for not pretending to melt and
wither away on contact, I’ll never forget the lesson that I learned
that day:
Even within those bonds born of love and faith, we travel different paths. Who am I to judge the way that is right?
This is but one of my many memories associated with my ongoing Commitment for Choice. It is a personal memory… A personal reflection. And today, on the anniversary of Roe v. Wade, I wanted to share it with you as well as a bit of food for thought:
The abortion debate often boils down to semantics. Is it a baby? Is it murder? Is it moral? Is it just? Plenty of questions with plenty of people willing to step-up and give you plenty of answers. Fortunately for you, I'm not one of those people.
I won't tell you that abortion is wrong.
I won't tell you that abortion is right.
What I will tell you is this:
In no way, shape, or form should any government have the power to tell a person that their body is no longer their own- that the choice is no longer theirs. Yes, today we're arguing over the semantics of a medical procedure… But if we continue to sit idly by and loose our right to choose, tomorrow we'll be arguing about our rights to even conceive at all.
Don't let that happen.


Mr Lady
Tuesday, 22 January, 2008 at 18:24Word. Word Up.
Amy @ M&M of a Mommy
Tuesday, 22 January, 2008 at 18:31That post gave me chills.
I commend you for standing up for your beliefs.
I believe the same. As a Christian I have kept this a secret from people in my church, I think I am afraid that someone will throw holy water on me and totally miss the point.
God teaches us grace and forgiveness. God is a proponent of free will. It is not my job to judge other peoples decisions, or make those decisions for them. It is my job to love, forgive and extend grace.
Thank you for this brave post.
Jenni
Tuesday, 22 January, 2008 at 18:46Even though we have completely opposing views on abortion, I think we both feel the same way about that woman.
I will never change another person's mind with hatred. And I have, unfortunately, seen too much of it from people who are claiming to love the unborn babies.
You are an amazing writer.
Tasina
Tuesday, 22 January, 2008 at 19:24I am completely baffled by people who hate gleefully. I always imagine that such people are the direct relatives of those people you see in old photographs of lynchings. I don't believe that woman had a well-thought out, morally defensible reason for what she did. She has no belief system – she just takes pleasure in hating. She has no opinion on the topic at all – she's just parroting placards and spewing unpleasantness. I find that such people often get back what they put out into the world. Mostly – I feel really sorry for her.
MommyTime
Tuesday, 22 January, 2008 at 22:00This is such an articulate and thoughtful post. And so are your commenters: "I am completely baffled by people who hate gleefully." All I can say is, me too. And this is right on. Thanks for this.
jewels
Tuesday, 22 January, 2008 at 22:36To me that is the difference between those who truely believe in something and those who believe because of another belief. If that makes sense at all. The freedom of choice is a gift, we can not let anyone take that from us.
Alison
Wednesday, 23 January, 2008 at 1:06Very well said…I agree with you 100%!!
christine
Wednesday, 23 January, 2008 at 9:57I know this post deals with some much bigger issues but I am still dreamy over the pretty boy with a guitar writing you a love song
I'm green with envy
kickass post
Maria
Wednesday, 23 January, 2008 at 15:52Kudos man. I loved it.
On Twitter: @ maria0305
Qweenie
Wednesday, 23 January, 2008 at 16:30One of my all time favorites….
BoyOHBoy (Jenn)
Wednesday, 23 January, 2008 at 19:19This is a wonderful post. People seem to overlook the fact that Pro Choice does not necessarily mean Pro Abortion. It means FOR CHOICE. For a women's right to choose for herself & make choices that pertain to her own body. No government has the right to make the choices for anyone.
Fantastic & thoughtful post. And fantastic & thoughtful responses.
Kim
Wednesday, 23 January, 2008 at 20:16"In no way, shape, or form should any government have the power to tell a person that their body is no longer their own- that the choice is no longer theirs. Yes, today we're arguing over the semantics of a medical procedure… But if we continue to sit idly by and loose our right to choose, tomorrow we'll be arguing about our rights to even conceive at all."
I wanted to highlight the majority of this entire post, but I took what pulled me in and kept me lingering at the words.. These are the words that made me want to stand up and clap.. not being corny either..Simply an amazing post.
Dawn
Wednesday, 23 January, 2008 at 21:58WORD.
(I'd try for an eloquent response, but I'm too occupied chewing on your words … in a good way.)
Sandy (Momisodes)
Wednesday, 23 January, 2008 at 22:52BTW…stop by momisodes when you can for an award (not a tag, promise)
cate
Wednesday, 23 January, 2008 at 23:06well said…much better than i could ever hope to put it to words.
melissa
Thursday, 24 January, 2008 at 9:26excellent post!!!
being pro-choice myself…i believe it is NOT about whether or not you believe abortion is right or wrong…it's about having the choice to decide what is right for YOU!!! and…NOT letting the government decide for you!
xoxo
On Twitter: @ rockdrool
Secret Agent Mama
Thursday, 24 January, 2008 at 11:05I am a Christian.
I am pro-choice.
This post. Eloquent. Superb. Totally Judith. I love thee, dear lady.
Rachel
Thursday, 24 January, 2008 at 15:23Brilliant honey.
It moved me today, just as it did when I first read it.
Big Dan
Saturday, 26 January, 2008 at 16:08You have my vote.
And doesn't everybody want to be a member of the Brat pack? Alas I'd probably end up being Duckie